Locations8 min read

We Buy Houses in Brookhaven NY: Serving All Brookhaven Towns

Need to sell your Brookhaven house? We buy homes in Port Jefferson, Patchogue, Mastic, Shirley, Coram, and Medford. Cash offers for any condition property.

B

Billy Alvaro

January 27, 2026

Brookhaven is the largest township on Long Island - and arguably the most diverse. From the historic charm of Port Jefferson to the affordable communities of Mastic and Shirley, this township spans from the Long Island Sound to the Great South Bay. We've been buying houses throughout Brookhaven for over 15 years, and we understand what makes each community unique.

I'm Billy Alvaro, and my company, Easy Sell Property Solutions, has purchased over $120 million in Long Island real estate. If you have a Brookhaven property you need to sell - in any condition, in any situation - we can make you a fair cash offer and close on your timeline.

The Brookhaven Advantage

Brookhaven's size and diversity create unique opportunities for homeowners looking to sell. Here's why many choose a cash sale:

Diverse Property Types Brookhaven has everything from waterfront estates to modest starter homes, rural properties to dense developments. Whatever you have, we're interested in buying it.

Varying Property Values Port Jefferson and Stony Brook command premium prices, while Mastic and Shirley are more affordable. We buy throughout the entire value spectrum.

Rural and Suburban Mix Some Brookhaven properties sit on large lots with well and septic systems. These can complicate traditional sales but don't concern us.

Older Housing Stock Much of Brookhaven was developed in the mid-20th century. Homes from the 1950s-1970s often need significant updates that make as-is sales attractive.

Brookhaven Neighborhoods We Serve

We purchase properties throughout Brookhaven Township, including:

Port Jefferson A charming village with a thriving downtown and harbor access. Properties here range from historic homes to newer construction. We buy throughout the area regardless of condition.

Port Jefferson Station Adjacent to the village but with a different character and more affordable prices. We purchase single-family homes and multi-family properties here.

Patchogue A revitalized downtown, waterfront access, and diverse housing stock make Patchogue attractive. From small capes to larger homes, we buy it all.

Mastic and Mastic Beach Affordable communities that sometimes struggle with property values. We buy extensively in this area, including homes with flood zone complications or deferred maintenance.

Shirley Between Mastic and the Hamptons, Shirley has a range of properties from modest homes to larger residences. We purchase throughout.

Coram A large hamlet with homes from various eras. Many Coram properties need updating, which is exactly what we specialize in.

Medford Centrally located with good access to the LIE, Medford has solid housing stock. We buy homes in any condition.

Bellport A historic village with charm and waterfront appeal. We purchase properties throughout Bellport regardless of condition.

Brookhaven Hamlet The community that gives the township its name, with a mix of homes and rural character.

Middle Island, Ridge, Yaphank Northern Brookhaven communities with larger lots and more rural feel. We buy properties with acreage, well/septic systems, and unique characteristics.

Our Simple Cash Buying Process

Selling to us is straightforward, no matter where you are in Brookhaven:

Step 1: Contact Us Call 631-400-EASY (3279) or fill out our online form. Tell us about your property - location, condition, and your situation.

Step 2: Property Visit We'll schedule a convenient time to see your home. This is a quick evaluation, not a detailed inspection. We're assessing the overall property to make a fair offer.

Step 3: Cash Offer Within 24-48 hours, you'll receive our offer. We explain our calculations and answer any questions. No pressure to accept.

Step 4: You Choose the Closing If you accept, you pick the closing date. Need to close quickly? We can do 7 days. Need more time? We'll wait.

What We Buy in Brookhaven

We purchase all types of residential properties:

  • **Single-family homes** (any size, any condition)
  • **Multi-family properties** (common in Port Jeff Station, Patchogue)
  • **Waterfront properties** (Great South Bay, Port Jeff Harbor, etc.)
  • **Large lot/rural properties** (well and septic don't concern us)
  • **Flood zone properties**
  • **Fire-damaged homes**
  • **Properties with code violations**
  • **Hoarder situations**
  • **Estate properties** with title complications

Common Brookhaven Selling Situations

Here's why Brookhaven homeowners call us:

**Inherited Property**: Brookhaven has many families who've been here for generations. When property passes to heirs who live elsewhere or can't maintain it, we provide a quick solution. We work with estates and handle probate complications.

**Behind on Payments**: The economy hasn't been kind to everyone. If you're facing foreclosure, we can often close fast enough to stop the process and protect your credit.

**Large Lot Complications**: Properties with acreage, well systems, or septic can be harder to sell traditionally. Buyers worry about these systems. We don't.

**Flood Zone Properties**: Mastic Beach and other waterfront areas have flood zone complications. We buy these properties without hesitation.

**Rental Property Exit**: Tired of being a landlord in Port Jeff Station or Patchogue? We'll buy your multi-family property, even with tenants in place.

**Major Repairs Needed**: That foundation issue, roof problem, or mold situation has traditional buyers running. We purchase as-is.

**Downsizing**: The kids are grown, and maintaining that big house in Coram or Medford is too much. Selling for cash means no showings, no waiting.

**Divorce**: When marriages end, quick property sales help everyone move forward. We provide fair valuations and fast closings.

Why Choose Us for Your Brookhaven Sale

With many buyers in the market, here's why Easy Sell stands out:

**Brookhaven Expertise**: We've been buying throughout this township for over 15 years. We know Port Jefferson values differ from Mastic. We understand the unique characteristics of each community.

**Volume Experience**: With over $120 million in purchases, we've seen every situation. Nothing surprises us or slows us down.

**Local Presence**: Our office is in nearby East Setauket. We're not investors calling from another state - we live and work in this community.

**Fair Offers**: We show you exactly how we calculate our price. No games, no hidden fees.

**Proven Results**: 70+ five-star Google reviews from real sellers throughout Long Island.

What You Get When Selling to Us

  • **No Repairs**: Sell exactly as-is - don't fix anything
  • **No Cleaning Out**: Leave furniture, belongings, debris
  • **No Commissions**: We're direct buyers, not agents
  • **No Closing Costs**: We pay standard fees
  • **Fast Closing**: As quick as 7 days
  • **Cash Advance**: Up to $10,000 before closing if needed
  • **Free Moving**: Local moving assistance anywhere on Long Island

Frequently Asked Questions

**Q: Do you buy properties with well and septic?** A: Absolutely. Many Brookhaven properties have private well and septic systems. We're experienced with these and purchase them regularly.

**Q: What about flood zone properties in Mastic Beach?** A: We buy flood zone properties throughout Brookhaven. We're experienced with the insurance and renovation requirements.

**Q: How do values vary across Brookhaven?** A: Significantly. Port Jefferson and Stony Brook areas command higher prices, while Mastic and Shirley are more affordable. Our offers reflect actual market values in each community.

**Q: Can you buy my rental property in Port Jeff Station?** A: Yes. We purchase multi-family properties throughout Brookhaven, often with tenants in place.

**Q: How fast can you really close?** A: Our fastest Brookhaven closing was 5 days. Most close within 2-3 weeks depending on title work.

Get Your Brookhaven Cash Offer

Whether your property is in Port Jefferson or Mastic, Patchogue or Coram, we're ready to make you a fair cash offer. Whatever the condition, whatever the situation, let's talk.

Call me at **631-400-EASY (3279)** or fill out our online form. Within 24 hours, you'll have a cash offer - no obligation, no pressure.

Brookhaven is our backyard. We've helped hundreds of families throughout this township sell their homes quickly and fairly. Let us do the same for you.

B

About Billy Alvaro

Billy Alvaro is the founder of Easy Sell Property Solutions, a family-run cash home buying company based in Long Island. With over 20 years of experience and $120M+ in transactions, Billy helps homeowners sell their properties quickly and hassle-free.

Learn more about our team →

Need to Sell Your House Fast?

Get a fair, no-obligation cash offer on your Long Island home today.

Ready to Sell Your House Fast?

Skip the hassle of repairs, showings, and waiting. Get a fair cash offer today.

Or call Billy directly:

631-400-EASY (3279)
No feesNo repairsNo obligationsCash in 7 days
Call NowGet Cash Offer