Inherited Property11 min read

Selling a House in Probate in NY: What Executors Should Know

Mom or Dad passed and the house is stuck in Surrogate's Court. Here's how selling a house in probate in New York actually works, from letters to closing, in plain English.

B

By Billy Alvaro

April 7, 2026

Probate legal documents with gavel and house keys on wooden desk

Need to sell your house fast?

Get a fair, no-obligation cash offer: no repairs, no fees, no commissions. Or call 631-400-EASY.

View our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Somebody just died. Maybe it was your mom, your dad, an aunt who never had kids. And now there's a house on Long Island with your name on the paperwork as executor, a stack of mail on the kitchen counter, and a lot of people asking you what the plan is.

I'm Billy Alvaro. I've been buying houses here since 2009, and probate houses are a big part of what we do. We said it on our radio show, Cashing Out: "We're doing a bunch of probate very recently where people just inherited properties. They're out of state." That's the most common call we get on these. The family is in Florida or the Carolinas, the house is in Suffolk or Nassau, and nobody knows where to start.

So let me lay out how this works in New York, what the court actually needs from you, and where people get stuck. I'm not a lawyer and this isn't legal advice. Your estate attorney is the one who signs off on the legal stuff. But I've sat at a lot of closings with executors, and I can tell you what the road looks like.

First Question: Does the House Even Go Through Probate?

Not always. Before you file anything, figure out how the house was titled. Pull the deed (the county clerk has it) and look at whose names are on it.

  • Owned jointly with a spouse or someone else with survivorship rights. If the deed says joint tenants with right of survivorship, or a married couple owned it as tenants by the entirety, the house usually passes straight to the surviving owner. No probate needed for the house.
  • In a trust. If Mom put the house in a living trust, the trustee handles it under the trust. Different process, usually faster.
  • Transfer on death deed. New York started allowing these on July 19, 2024 (Real Property Law section 424). If one was signed and recorded, the house goes to the named beneficiary without probate. These are still pretty new, so most of the estates we see don't have one.
  • In the deceased person's name alone. This is the one that goes to Surrogate's Court. If there's a will, it's a probate proceeding. If there's no will, it's an administration proceeding.

One more thing people ask about: New York has a "small estate" shortcut called voluntary administration for estates with $50,000 or less in personal property. It does not cover a house in the deceased person's sole name. The court's own guidance says so. If there's a house in their name alone, you're filing a full proceeding.

The New York Process, Step by Step

Probate in New York runs through the Surrogate's Court in the county where the person lived. For Long Island that's the Nassau County Surrogate's Court in Mineola or the Suffolk County Surrogate's Court in Riverhead. If your father lived in Queens, it's Queens County, even if you live in New Jersey.

If there's a will: letters testamentary

The executor named in the will files a probate petition with the original will and a certified death certificate. The court needs to hear from the "distributees," which is the legal word for the people who would inherit if there were no will. They can sign waivers and consents, or the court sends them a formal notice called a citation and gives them a date to show up and object.

If everybody signs the waivers and the will is clean, the judge admits the will and issues letters testamentary. That piece of paper is your authority. Title companies, banks, and buyers will all ask for a copy.

If there's no will: letters of administration

A close relative petitions to be appointed administrator. New York law sets the order of who inherits (spouse and children first, then parents, then siblings, and so on), and the court wants consent or notice from those people too. When it's approved you get letters of administration.

Here's the part nobody tells you. Letters of administration sometimes come with restrictions printed right on them. A common one says the administrator can't sell real property without a further court order. Read your letters before you list the house or sign a contract. If there's a restriction, your attorney has to go back to the court to get it lifted or get approval for the sale.

How long does it take?

I'm not gonna give you one number, because there isn't one. A simple estate where everyone signs waivers can get letters in a few months. Courts are busy, though, and a missing heir, a will with a problem, or one sibling who refuses to sign can stretch it out to a year or more. Your attorney will know how fast your county is moving right now. Ask them.

Can You Sell a House During Probate in New York?

Yes, once you have your letters. You can't close before that. Nobody can legally sign the deed for the estate until the court appoints somebody.

What happens after that depends on what the will says and what your letters say.

An executor usually doesn't need a judge to sell. New York's estate law (EPTL 11-1.1) gives an executor the power to sell estate property, on terms the executor thinks are best for the people who inherit, unless the will takes that power away. Most wills drafted by an attorney spell out a power of sale anyway.

You may need court approval when:

  • The will specifically leaves the house to a particular person. The executor's built-in power to sell doesn't apply to property that's "specifically disposed of."
  • The will says the executor can't sell.
  • Your letters of administration are restricted, like I described above.

In those cases your attorney petitions the Surrogate's Court for permission. It adds time. It isn't the end of the world, and estate attorneys do it all the time.

Even when you don't legally need everyone's sign-off, get the family on the same page before you sell. An executor has a duty to act in the best interest of everybody who inherits. Selling the house out from under a sibling who wanted to keep it is how you end up in front of the judge anyway.

Where Probate Sales Actually Get Stuck

The paperwork is the paperwork. What slows these deals down is almost always one of these.

The family can't agree

On the radio we told people, "You might call us and say listen, my family's been fighting for the last 10, 15 years." We get that call. Sometimes my cousin Wayne and I end up in the middle of it, sitting between brothers and sisters who see the house differently and helping them get to one answer. Nobody wins those fights. A clear number on the table, in writing, helps everybody stop arguing about what the house is "worth" in their head.

Nobody lives nearby

This one comes up constantly. The kids moved away years ago and they can't drop everything to fly up and deal with a house. Some of them just can't face walking back in. Wayne said it on the show: "It's sometimes so hard, they can't even come back up here." That's not a character flaw. That's grief.

The house is full

Forty years of living fills a house. When we talked about cleanouts on the show, the line was "you could spend 10, 15 grand, folks, to clean out, if not more." That's real. A two-story colonial with a full basement and a detached garage can mean a lot of dumpsters, and every one costs money.

The paperwork on the house itself

If you inherited a house, you have no idea what Dad built over the years. The deck, the finished basement, the converted garage. If the town has no permit or certificate of occupancy on file for those, a buyer with a mortgage is going to find out at the worst possible time. Go to the town building department, pull whatever is on file, and know before you list.

Carrying the house while you wait

The taxes, insurance, utilities, and lawn don't stop because someone passed. If the house is vacant, call the insurance company. A lot of homeowner's policies treat a vacant house differently, and you don't want to learn that after a pipe bursts in January.

Your Options for Selling

Once you have authority to sell, you've basically got two roads.

List it with a realtor. If the house is in decent shape, the family can wait, and somebody can handle showings and repairs, listing it may get you the highest price. That's the truth, and I'll tell you that on the phone too. You'll pay commission, you may have to fix what the buyer's inspector finds, and the buyer's mortgage has to come through.

Sell it as-is to a cash buyer. The price will usually be lower than a top-of-the-market retail sale. What you get in exchange is no repairs, no cleanout, no showings, and a closing date you pick. For an executor who lives three states away, or a family that's fighting, that's often worth more than the difference.

Bottom line: run both numbers. If you want to see the math on that, I broke it down in cash buyer vs. realtor.

How We Handle Probate Houses

Here's what we do when an executor calls us. None of this is a script. It's what we've actually done.

We don't chase you. When I first started, I sent out a letter the way some guru taught me, basically "sorry your father died, want to sell?" I got a ton of calls and not one deal, because every single person who called screamed at me. They were right. I learned that lesson early. We tell families we're here when they're ready, and a lot of them call us after their attorney says "we just got the probate done."

We'll talk before your letters come in. You can call us while the petition is still pending. We'll look at the house and tell you what we'd pay, so you and your attorney can plan. We just can't close until you have authority.

We buy it as-is, with the stuff inside. Take what matters to you and leave the rest. For families out of state, we've had a professional company pack up the belongings that mattered and ship them down to Florida and North Carolina. Wayne said it best: "They don't want to come back because it's just such an emotional hardship."

We work with your estate attorney. If the court has to approve the sale, we give your attorney what they need and we wait for the order. On some deals we've helped with the seller's attorney fees or the transfer tax. Every deal is different, so ask.

We close on your timeline. If you have authority and want to close fast, we can do it in as little as 7 days. If you need three months to get the family sorted out, that works too. We back it with our 7-day closing guarantee: if we agree to seven days and miss it on our end, you get a $1,000 credit at closing.

We can help with costs before closing. Estates sometimes need money for taxes or expenses before the sale. Our cash advance program can put up to $10,000 in your hands before closing.

If you want the full walk-through of how a sale with us goes, it's on our how it works page. There's more on inherited houses specifically on our inherited house page.

A Quick Word on New Jersey

We buy in New Jersey too, and the probate process there is different. It's handled by the Surrogate's office in the county where the person lived, there's a short waiting period after the death before letters can be issued, and an uncontested will can often move quicker than in New York. New Jersey also has an inheritance tax, and depending on who inherits, the estate may need a tax waiver before the house can be sold. If the house is in Jersey, talk to a New Jersey estate attorney about those steps.

Questions Executors Ask Me

Can I sell the house before probate is finished?

You can't sell before you're appointed, meaning before you have letters. After that, you usually don't have to wait until the whole estate is wrapped up. Plenty of executors sell the house early because it's the biggest asset and the one costing money every month.

Do all the heirs have to agree?

Not always, legally. If the will gives the executor a power of sale, the executor can generally sell. But if a will leaves the house to a specific person, or your letters are restricted, you'll need court approval. Either way, get buy-in from the family if you can. Your attorney can tell you exactly where you stand.

What happens to the mortgage?

The mortgage doesn't disappear when the owner dies. It gets paid off from the sale at closing, just like any other sale. Keep the payments current if the estate can, and let your attorney talk to the lender.

Will we owe capital gains tax?

Usually much less than people expect. Inherited property generally gets a "stepped-up basis," which means your starting value is what the house was worth on the date of death, not what Mom paid in 1974. If you sell close to that value, the taxable gain is often small. Talk to the estate's accountant, and read our post on inherited property taxes in New York.

What if one sibling is living in the house?

That's common, and it's sensitive. The executor's job is to protect the estate's asset for everybody. Sometimes that means a buyout, sometimes a sale with a move-out date that gives the sibling time to land somewhere. This is one to work through with your attorney before you sign anything.

What if the house is a mess, or there are open permits?

We buy those. The uglier the better, honestly. No cleanout, no repairs, no running around the building department.

You Don't Have to Figure It Out Alone

If you're the executor and you're sitting on a house you didn't ask for, give us a call at 631-400-EASY (3279). One of our team will talk through where you are in the court process and what the house needs. If we're a fit, we'll make you an offer. If we're not, we'll point you in the right direction and we part as friends.

You can also request your offer online whenever you're ready. Take your time. There's no wrong time to ask a question.

For more on what heirs go through after the court part is done, read selling an inherited house on Long Island.

B

About Billy Alvaro

Billy Alvaro is the founder of Easy Sell Property Solutions, a family-run cash home buying company based in Long Island. In business since 2009 with $120M+ in transactions, Billy helps homeowners sell their properties quickly and hassle-free.

Read Billy's story →

Need to Sell Your House Fast?

Get a fair, no-obligation cash offer on your Long Island home today.

Ready to Sell Your House Fast?

Skip the hassle of repairs, showings, and waiting. Get a fair cash offer today.

View our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Or call Billy directly:

631-400-EASY (3279)
No feesNo repairsNo obligationsCash in 7 days